Django ImportError Hiding
A little while ago I was asked what my biggest gripe with Django was. At the time I couldn’t think of a good answer because since I started using Django in the pre-1.0 days most of the rough edges have been smoothed. Yesterday though, I encountered an error that made me wish I thought of it at the time.
The code that produced the error looked like this:
from django.db import models class MyModel(model.Model): ... def save(self): models.Model.save(self) ... ...
The error that was raised was AttributeError: 'NoneType' object has no attribute 'Model'. This means that rather than containing a module object, models was None. Clearly this is impossible as the class could not have been created if that was the case. Impossible or not, it was clearly happening.
Adding a print statement to the module showed that when it was imported the models variable did contain the expected module object. What that also showed was that module was being imported more than once, something that should also be impossible.
After a wild goose chase investigating reasons why the module might be imported twice I tracked it down to the load_app method in django/db/models/loading.py. The code there looks something like this:
def load_app(self, app_name, can_postpone=False): try: models = import_module('.models', app_name) except ImportError: # Ignore exception
Now I’m being a harsh here, and the exception handler does contain a comment about working out if it should reraise the exception. The issue here is that it wasn’t raising the exception, and it’s really not clear why. It turns out that I had a misspelt module name in an import statement in a different module. This raised an ImportError which was caught, hidden and then Django repeatedly attempted to import the models as they were referenced in the models of other apps. The strange exception that was originally encountered is probably an artefact of Python’s garbage collection, although how exactly it occurred is still not clear to me.
There are a number of tickets (#6379, #14130 and probably others) on this topic. A common refrain in Python is that it’s easier to ask for forgiveness than to ask for permission, and I certainly agree with Django and follow that most of the time.
I always follow the rule that try/except clauses should cover as little code as possible. Consider the following piece of code.
try: var.method1() var.member.method2() except AttributeError: # handle error
Which of the three attribute accesses are we actually trying to catch here? Handling exceptions like this are a useful way of implementing Duck Typing while following the easier to ask forgiveness principle. What this code doesn’t make clear is which member or method is actually optional. A better way to write this would be:
var.method1() try: member = var.member except AttributeError: # handle error else: member.method2()
Now the code is very clear that the var variable may or may not have a member member variable. If method1 or method2 do not exist then the exception is not masked and is passed on. Now lets consider that we want to allow the method1 attribute to be optional.
try: var.method1() except AttributeError: # handle error
At first glance it’s obvious that method1 is optional, but actually we’re catching too much here. If there is a bug in method1 that causes an AttributeError to raised then this will be masked and the code will treat it as if method1 didn’t exist. A better piece of code would be:
try: method = var.method1 except AttributeError: # handle error else: method()
ImportErrors are similar because code can be executed, but then when an error occurs you can’t tell whether the original import failed or whether an import inside that failed. Unlike with an AttributeError there is a no easy way to rewrite the code to only catch the error you’re interested in. Python does provide some tools to divide the import process into steps, so you can tell whether the module exists before attempting to import it. In particular the imp.find_module function would be useful.
Changing Django to avoid catching the wrong ImportErrors will greatly complicate the code. It would also introduce the danger that the algorithm used would not match the one used by Python. So, what’s the moral of this story? Never catch more exceptions than you intended to, and if you get some really odd errors in your Django site watch out for ImportErrors.